ASML Drops, TSMC Rises

Advertisements

The semiconductor industry operates under an intricate web of relationships and technological advancements, where giants like ASML and TSMC play polarizing roles amid fluctuating market conditionsAs the market for advanced chips evolves, the dynamics between these two companies provide a fascinating case studyIn late October, a stark contrast emerged between ASML, the leading lithography equipment manufacturer, and TSMC, a titan in the chip foundry sector, presenting a tale of two fates in the tech industry.

ASML found itself grappling with a crisis that seemed to strike at the heart of its operationsWithin a span of just two days, the company witnessed a catastrophic decline in its stock price, leading to a staggering loss of approximately 20% of its market capitalizationThe cause of this turmoil was largely attributed to internal technical problems, leading to an early and unintended leak of their financial documents

While ASML reported revenue and profit figures that exceeded market expectations, the significant decrease in its order book raised alarm bellsMajor clients like Samsung and Intel began to pull back on their orders for Extreme Ultraviolet (EUV) lithography machines, fueling concerns over ASML's future sales and profits.

As the demand for EUV machines dwindled, the forecast for orders from the Chinese mainland appeared even more ominous, with predictions suggesting a nearly 40% reduction in Deep Ultraviolet (DUV) lithography orders by 2025 due to ongoing technology restrictions and export bansThe semiconductor sector is clearly divided into two primary categories of lithography machines: EUV machines, essential for crafting cutting-edge chips below 7 nanometers, and DUV machines, which cater to chips ranging from 7 to 180 nanometersASML's revenue heavily relies on EUV and advanced DUV machines, making its business vulnerable to the fortunes of its high-profile clients.

Altogether, ASML finds itself in treacherous waters as the very industry it predominantly serves starts to face challenges

Samsung and Intel, once stalwarts of high-end chip development, are struggling, which has directly affected their order volumes from ASMLThis precarious situation serves as a warning regarding the complexities and interdependencies within the semiconductor value chain.

Contrasting with ASML's struggles, TSMC's recent financial performance showcases a bright horizon for the chip manufacturing giantIn stark contrast to ASML's decline, TSMC reported an astounding revenue of $23.5 billion for the third quarter, marking a staggering 39% growth year-on-yearThis notable surge not only set new milestones for TSMC but also highlighted its formidable profitability and competitive strength in the semiconductor landscapeA deep dive into TSMC's revenue structure reveals that its advanced manufacturing processes, especially those at or below 7 nanometers, contributed significantly—accounting for as much as 70% of the company’s revenue.

Particularly noteworthy is TSMC's 3-nanometer process, which alone generates 20% of its total revenue, thanks to the patronage of at least seven industry-leading companies opting for TSMC’s services

This not only demonstrates TSMC's commanding position in the advanced chip market but also reflects the growing trust from major clients in the company’s manufacturing capabilitiesMoreover, TSMC has established a solid infrastructure around its 5-nanometer process, which continues to contribute around 32% to its revenues, indicating TSMC's ongoing evolution and adaptability in the rapidly shifting landscape of semiconductor fabrication.

As TSMC pursues its expansion, the burgeoning demand for 2-nanometer chips presents exciting opportunities aheadThe company is proactively preparing to ramp up production capacities to meet this anticipated demand, which will further solidify its status as a leader in the chip foundry spaceBehind TSMC's robust performance lies not just the advanced process technologies but also its innovation in chip packaging technologies, such as CoWoS, which boasts a yield rate exceeding 99%. This efficient packaging has become a benchmark in the industry and underscores TSMC's advantage over its counterparts, especially in the burgeoning field of AI chip manufacturing.

Examining the differences between ASML and TSMC reveals three significant dimensions

alefox

First, there is the established technological moatASML specializes in lithography technology, a critical facet of semiconductor manufacturing, yet its market is facing stagnation from gradual diminishing returns under Moore's LawIn contrast, TSMC’s business thrives on a robust ecosystem of clients, creating a virtuous cycle that continuously feeds its growthSecondly, the two companies diverge starkly in terms of pricing power: ASML, with its high-end machines sitting with little to no demand, struggles to price its products, while TSMC capitalizes on a chip supply-demand imbalance, allowing it to set competitive prices on its servicesLastly, their business models differ fundamentally: TSMC operates within a realm of incremental gains, where any upward trend in chip demand translates directly to orders, while ASML relies on foundries expanding their manufacturing capabilities—an unpredictable scenario impacted by a multitude of external factors.

The road ahead presents challenges and opportunities for both companies