Microsoft's Bitcoin Investment Proposal Rejected
Advertisements
In a surprising turn of events during Microsoft’s annual virtual shareholder meeting, Michael Saylor, the CEO of MicroStrategy Inc., found himself advocating for a cause that didn’t quite resonate with the tech giant’s board. Despite his fervent calls for Microsoft to invest in Bitcoin, a decision was firmly rebuffed. Saylor, who has transformed MicroStrategy from a once-obscure firm into a prominent player in the Bitcoin space, presented his conviction and strong beliefs regarding digital currencies. Under his leadership, the company amassed over $40 billion in Bitcoin, positioning it as a significant player in the cryptocurrency market.
During the shareholder meeting, Saylor emphasized the potential benefits of diversifying Microsoft’s balance sheet through Bitcoin. He proposed a measure that would require the board to consider the inclusion of cryptocurrencies as a viable asset to protect shareholders' long-term interests against inflation. However, the resolution faced opposition and was ultimately rejected by a large portion of the investors. As noted by Ethan Peck, Vice President of the Free Enterprise Project—a group that championed a similar proposal before the Amazon board—such attempts may not be unique to Microsoft but could become increasingly commonplace amongst major corporations.
The board of Microsoft had previously assessed the idea of investing in cryptocurrencies and deemed it unsuitable. They were backed in their decision by advisory firms such as Glass Lewis and Institutional Shareholder Services. These agencies cautioned that, according to expert studies, there was no guarantee that including cryptocurrencies in the investment portfolio would enhance returns. Keith D. Olivieri, Microsoft’s Deputy General Counsel, articulated the board's stance, expressing their conviction that the proposal did not warrant support.

This rejection, however, seems unlikely to stifle future attempts of the sort. The burgeoning cryptocurrency market has attracted attention as Bitcoin prices surged more than double this year. Many advocates argue for corporate investments in Bitcoin to hedge against inflation, a sentiment that is gaining traction among shareholders. With prominent investors like BlackRock, State Street, and FMR LLC taking notable positions in cryptocurrency ventures, their influence might lead to more substantial involvement in the sector. As shareholders grow more engaged in discussions related to cryptocurrencies, board members may have to contend with shifting opinions that push them to reconsider their current strategies.
One factor driving the search for crypto investments is the more favorable regulatory environment surrounding cryptocurrencies, particularly as some lawmakers express eagerness to embrace this evolving landscape. In recent months, discussions surrounding government-backed Bitcoin reserves have flourished. For instance, Cynthia Lummis, a senator from Wyoming, has proposed a plan for the U.S. government to purchase one million Bitcoins within five years and hold them for at least two decades, thus indicating a significant shift in attitude towards the asset.
Eswar Prasad, a trade policy professor at Cornell University, commented on the viability of cryptocurrency investments. He remarked that considering the positive outlook for the cryptocurrency sector under government support, it would be prudent for companies to allocate a small portion of their reserves into Bitcoin, despite acknowledging the high risks involved. This growing acknowledgment among financial experts emphasizes the need for companies to explore innovative financial strategies to safeguard their assets in a volatile economic climate.
More corporations are exploring Bitcoin investments, with organizations such as MARA Holdings Inc., Block Inc., and Tesla jumping on board. Not to forget, MicroStrategy has been consistently acquiring Bitcoin since 2020, showcasing Saylor's deep belief in the asset’s potential. Nevertheless, the risk of a significant downturn in the cryptocurrency market looms large. A hypothetical scenario wherein Bitcoin experiences a drastic reversal could spell disaster for those heavily invested. This was illustrated when Saylor stepped down as CEO in 2022 to focus solely on advocating for Bitcoin after the cryptocurrency's value fell sharply.
At the meeting, Saylor implored investors with a resounding message: “If you want to beat the market, you need Bitcoin.” He stated that embracing such a strategy could very well lead to stock prices soaring. In a presentation shared in advance on social media platform X, Saylor projected a remarkable growth of Bitcoin's market cap, estimating it could rise from $2 trillion to more than $200 trillion within 21 years. He emphasized that Bitcoin’s historical performance had outpaced Microsoft's stock value by a factor of ten.
Interestingly, Peck, representing the Free Enterprise Project, suggested that if Microsoft’s CEO Satya Nadella were agreeable to a private meeting with Saylor, they would retract the proposal. Unfortunately, Microsoft declined this offer, emphasizing their position against contributing to the proposal raised by Saylor and his allies.
Peck passionately concluded, “What we really want is sound money that prevents shareholders from losing due to inflation.” He asserted that Bitcoin’s track record thus far supports its candidacy as a solid solution to the pressing concerns faced by investors in the modern economic landscape.